Choose X when the offered upgrade improves a job the card already does well and you need more of that effect. Choose Y when its listed change fills a different gap or gives you a useful combination. The letters are a starting point, and the card text tells you what you will actually get.
What X and Y usually change
IGN's publisher-sponsored HARMA overview describes X as commonly improving the card's existing effect or adding more of the same card type to your deck. That can mean a stronger attack, shield, or heal. Some increases depend on how many artifact attunements succeed.
Y often changes how you can use the card. An option might offer different card draws or an additional effect that creates a useful synergy. Check what the particular version says before assuming every Y is more flexible or every X changes a number.
Pick the version that solves a specific problem
| What your deck needs | What to check |
|---|---|
| More damage or protection from a card you already play often | Check whether X actually improves that effect and which attunements it asks for. |
| More ways to reach the cards you need | Check whether Y adds a draw effect you can use on the turns when your hand runs short. |
| Better performance when only a few artifacts attune | Compare both effects under the same conditions. Pay attention to what they do on your usual turn. |
Suppose one version of a shield card adds more shield and the other gives access to an extra effect. Choose more shielding if surviving the incoming hit is what usually costs you the fight. If you are already blocking enough, ask whether the other effect helps you follow up while you still have a useful turn.
Finish reading before committing
Read both effects when the selection opens. The official 0.7.0.17 patch notes say the HARMA card upgrade selection can no longer be dismissed. Check the card text at the screen, including any requirement for an improved effect, rather than planning to come back after the next fight.
FAQ
Does X always improve damage?
X can also strengthen effects like shield or healing, or change the number of copies. Check the specific card.
Does every Y upgrade draw cards?
Some Y upgrades change what you draw. Others add a different effect or create a synergy.
Do X and Y also appear after fusion?
They can appear as choices for a card that comes out of fusion. The fusion result has an element of chance.